The Chieftain Irish Pub is a typical pub, a stone’s throw away from San Francisco’s famous Moscone Center.
Ambiance
The Chieftain is an ok Irish pub. It’s not too fancy, it’s not too dirty (in fact, it’s not even a little dirty), and in general it’s unremarkable. But, that’s the problem: there’s nothing about the Chieftain that caused me to pause and take in my surroundings. It’s just a place in which I can have a drink and nothing more. (20/30)
Meh (15/30)
Drink Selection
A good drink selection. (5/5)
I had Lagunitas (again!), and it was good. My friend got a Guinness and the pour looked correct, so I’d definitely recommend getting that. They look like they have a decent beer selection, which you’d expect in a pub. However, they did not have Strongbow, which is my favorite cider, and a drink I think an Irish pub should carry. (10/15)
Location
The location is ok. It’s about a five minute walk from BART, making it convenient for East Bayers and BARTers from down south. But, aside from convenience the location is just ok–nothing to keep me coming back. (11/15)
Not the most exciting or interesting part of town. BUT, I didn’t see any crackheads or vomit anywhere, so the neighborhood was decent, if unremarkable. (4/5)
Music
I can’t even remember what was playing. The music was on low and didn’t obstruct our conversation. But, then again, it didn’t help create the kind of environment you’d expect in a good Irish pub. (5/10)
Ditto – I can’t remember music either. However, they do get props for not having the music too loud – that can ruin an evening for me. (15/30)
Price
At $5 for a pint of Lagunitas and $6 for a pint of Guinness, the Chieftain is not going to win any prizes for value. (32/40)
I think the prices are fair given that the beer is good, they are located in downtown SF, and they are about the same price as their neighbors. (15/20)
Total Score
I won’t be going back here unless I don’t have a choice. (73/100)
I’ve been to better. I’ve been to worse. For an Irish pub, I think you could find a funner, more authentic place in San Francisco. This one is merely conveniently located if you’re already down by the Metreon and have too much self-respect to get drunk at Jillian’s. (59/100)
The Chieftain Irish Pub gets a final score of 66 out of 100.